Rethinking Dog Obedience: Why Perfect Heeling Isn’t What Your Dog Needs
What is an obedient dog? There are probably more answers to this question now than ever before because people enjoy spending time with dogs in many different ways.
Some people might imagine a focused dog walking beside a person, while others picture a dog settling calmly at their owner’s feet as they enjoy a meal at a dog-friendly outdoor restaurant.
While there’s no single definition of an obedient dog, training should focus on what’s in the dog’s best interest and what you intend to use the training for. Training should keep dogs safe and help them be well-mannered in our communities, but it shouldn’t take away what they need as dogs.
Defining Modern Dog Obedience vs. Traditional Expectations
Traditional obedience training, such as the kind in which people compete with their dogs and earn titles, involves several skills. One core skill is heeling, when the dog walks beside the person. The dog stays focused on the person as they change pace, turn, and stop. When they stop, the dog quickly sits at the person’s side. It’s fascinating to watch and rewarding to train for.

Focused Heel Work: A Fun Game Rather Than a Constant Rule
Clear, precise criteria can make training fun. I enjoy the challenge of teaching dogs to keep their heads up and walk with motivation, even when I purposely place distractions, such as food, on the floor. I use the cue “heel” for this (or “close” if the dog is on the right), but I don’t require my dogs to heel for a long walk outside together. Instead, I mostly encourage them to sniff and explore or walk politely without requiring attention. I try not to interrupt curiosity. Heel work becomes a rewarding game I can cue, rather than a constant requirement. The result is a dog that can easily switch between focus and breaks.
Dogs can learn so many skills. Some skills make life safer for dogs and the people who interact with them. Some are fun tricks that require thinking. To the dog, it’s all the same. For example, you might teach your dog to put their front paws on a step or bucket. Your dog stays on the step until you give a release signal. It seems like a trick, but the concept is the same as teaching your dog to sit and stay until released.
Loose Leash Walking vs. Obedience: Finding the Balance
When it comes to leash walking, obedience training isn’t the complete solution. Of course, dogs should learn to walk with focus at times because it makes navigating crowds or distractions easier. It’s also fun to train a focused heel as long as you keep sessions short and include plenty of play. As in the step-up trick versus sit-stay example, your dog doesn’t know the difference between what you call an obedience skill and any other skill you train. While the heel cue has a start and end, the more relaxed, but still polite, leash walking style should always be the rule. Both take practice.
One perspective is to think of obedience training as a fun activity that helps you and your dog build a way to communicate outside of training practice, but it’s not the whole picture. You can keep challenging your dog through obedience training games and make the exercises more difficult, but it’s more of a conversation with your dog than a matter of control. What dogs learn in training can improve communication outside training, letting you enjoy more activities with your dog without requiring constant, robotic focus.
RANKED: Here Are the 63 Smartest Dog Breeds
Gallery Credit: Sabienna Bowman








